Wednesday, January 29, 2020

I, Anna – An Underappreciated Film starring Charlotte Rampling and Gabriel Byrne

What it is. . . a film review

The title of this film should be a clue this is not a fast-paced detective thriller, but more of a character study.   The film hinges entirely on the Anna character, and who better to reflect the emotional nuances than Charlotte Rampling. 

Anna is a gentile woman too young to give up living and too old to easily fit in to the cruel world she’s lost in.  As a lost woman, her life is a mix of fact and fantasy, with loneliness being the predominant theme. Her eyes, her reticence, her elegant figure convey only a small part of her mystery.  You find out slowly, as if by drip torture, that she’s being crushed by traumas of her own making.

We meet her first in one of those meet and mingle affairs held for lonely middle-aged people without partners, a scene that is at once depressing  and pitiful.  In an early sequuence, the cinematographer cuts to snap profiles of battered people looking for human companionship in a dreary human landscape.  A bull-headed man has dandruff on his shoulders.  A skinny would-be prospect is missing more teeth than a two year old.  For another man, it’s all about all-too-eager serial sex with the presumption that Anna is there for the same reason.  Lots of people, no prospects.

I can’t say whether Anna’s social encounters are more or less depressing than today’s computerized speed dating and sex delivery services but  one of Anna’s problems is that she outclasses just about everyone at the ‘party,’ as the group meetings are termed by the hotel hosts.   Leaving the hotel she brushes by Detective Chief Inspector Bernie Reid, another lost and lonely soul who has recently separated from his wife. The detective becomes infatuated, finds in Anna’s remote personality some semblance of his own. 

So far as genre goes, people are calling it ‘film noir,’ but though dark shadows are ever present in the film style, that seems more convenient that describing what it really is.  There is a story arc – a murder in the beginning and the detective ferreting out the killer in the end — but the entanglements are interesting and often excruciating.  I would acknowledge that the ‘noir’ description fits   murder victim George Stone, a peach of a man who violently forces fellatio on Anna and otherwise brutalizes her. 

The story develops in a sufficiently mysterious way that doesn’t flinch at large and small telltale signs of a woman falling apart. The thing about Anna is that the more she falls apart the more the story comes together. It’s all pretty clear at the end, and there’s even a little Faulkneresque scene   (A Rose for Emily) toward the end where we get a peek into the closed off baby’s room.  There are serious cracks in the walls of Anna’s mind.

So my hit on it is that the film is largely unappreciated as the artistic tight piece that it is.  It’s not a film of fuzzy warm characters the Hollywood formula demands you must relate to.  Though it’s not overly highbrow,  I would recommend it to people of an artistic persuasion who are fond of fine acting, and from the minor characters as well.  Anna has a sort of broken elegance about her that makes you worry that, if you would take your eyes off the road for just a split second, you could fall as far and as fast as Anna does.